I ordered (last year) four cushions and this was sent as two separate shipments. Two cushions had button indentations and the other two cushions had stitching indentations. See photos. Although the colors look different in the photo, (lighting different? one in sun, other chair in shade) they are the exact color so I never thought anything of this, but I will offer my opinion, think about choosing a patterned cushion! The dirt accumulates in these indentations that I’m constantly cleaning them. Wouldn’t be quite so noticeable in a patter lol. Comfortable yes! And color is beautiful – paprika orange/red. Bright, not muted. Live in the Midwest, so these are out all summer, through all weather conditions, storms, hot sun, rain, etc. After one full summer of use, still looks new. ..More